MSCI Hardball Strategy: What Did the 12-Page Defense Open Letter Say? As a finance and blockchain translation expert, you are familiar with the slang and terms used in the field. Please translate the following content into English while maintaining th...
Original Title: "Strategy Takes on MSCI: The Ultimate Defense of DAT"
Original Author: KarenZ, Foresight News
The game regarding the development of the Digital Asset Treasury (DAT) industry is still ongoing.
In October, the global index provider MSCI put forward a proposal to exclude companies with 50% or more of their assets in digital assets from its Global Investable Market Index. This move directly threatens the market position of digital asset treasury companies represented by Strategy and could even reshape the entire flow of capital in the digital asset treasury industry.
According to data compiled by Bitcoin for Corporations, 39 companies could be excluded from the MSCI Global Investable Market Index. JPMorgan analysts previously warned that the exclusion of just Strategy alone could lead to nearly $2.8 billion in passive outflows, and if other index providers follow suit with this rule, outflows could reach as high as $8.8 billion.

Currently, the consultation period for MSCI's proposal will continue until December 31, 2025, with the final conclusion expected to be announced by January 15, 2026, and any adjustments will be formally implemented in the index review process in February 2026.
Facing this urgent situation, on December 10th, Strategy submitted a strongly worded 12-page open letter to the MSCI Stock Index Committee, jointly signed by the company's Executive Chairman and Founder Michael Saylor and President and CEO Phong Le, clearly expressing firm opposition to the proposal. The letter stated: "This proposal is severely misleading and will have profoundly destructive consequences on the interests of global investors and the development of the digital asset industry. We strongly demand that MSCI fully withdraw this plan."
Strategy's Four Core Defense Arguments
Digital Assets are the Revolutionary Foundation of Financial System Transformation
Strategy believes that MSCI's proposal underestimates the strategic value of Bitcoin and other digital assets. Since Satoshi Nakamoto introduced Bitcoin 16 years ago, this digital asset has gradually grown into a key part of the global economy, with a current market capitalization of around $1.85 trillion.
From Strategy's perspective, digital assets are far more than simple financial instruments; they represent a fundamental technological innovation capable of reshaping the global financial system—enterprises investing in Bitcoin-related infrastructure are building a new financial ecosystem, akin to leading companies in history that deeply engaged with a single emerging technology.
Similar to the 19th-century Standard Oil's deep drilling for oil extraction and 20th-century AT&T's nationwide telephone network construction, these enterprises, through forward-looking investments in core infrastructure, laid a solid foundation for subsequent economic transformation, eventually becoming industry benchmarks. Strategy believes that companies currently focusing on digital assets are following the path of these "technology pioneers" and should not be simplistically dismissed by traditional index rules.
DAT Operates as a Business Enterprise, Not a Passive Fund
This is the core argument Strategy makes—Digital Asset Treasury entities (DATs) are operational businesses with a complete business model, rather than passive investment funds holding Bitcoin. While Strategy currently holds over 600,000 Bitcoin, its core value does not rely on Bitcoin price fluctuations but on designing and launching unique "digital credit" instruments to create sustainable returns for shareholders.
Specifically, the "digital credit" instruments issued by Strategy include various types of preferred stocks covering fixed dividend rates, floating dividend rates, different priority levels, and credit protection clauses. By selling these instruments to raise funds used to accumulate more Bitcoin, as long as Bitcoin's long-term investment return exceeds Strategy's USD-denominated funding costs, it can provide stable returns to shareholders and clients. Strategy emphasizes that this "active operations + asset appreciation" model, distinct from the passive management logic of traditional investment funds or ETFs, should be considered a normal operating business.
At the same time, Strategy also questions why oil giants, real estate investment trusts (REITs), timber companies, and other entities can hold a concentrated single asset class without being classified as investment funds and excluded from the index. Establishing special restrictions only on digital asset companies evidently contradicts industry fairness principles.
A 50% Threshold for Digital Assets Is Arbitrary, Discriminatory, and Impractical
Strategy points out that MSCI's proposal adopts discriminatory standards. Many large companies in traditional industries also hold a single asset class in their assets, including oil and gas companies, real estate investment trusts, timber companies, and power infrastructure enterprises. However, MSCI has only established special exclusion criteria for digital asset companies, which constitutes obvious unfair treatment.
From an implementation feasibility standpoint, this proposal also faces significant issues. Due to the volatile nature of digital asset prices, the same company may repeatedly enter and exit the MSCI Index within a few days due to asset value fluctuations, causing market confusion. Furthermore, differences between accounting standards (U.S. GAAP and international IFRS standards treat digital assets differently) will result in companies with the same business model receiving disparate treatment based on their jurisdiction.
Violating Index Neutrality Principle by Injecting Policy Bias
Strategy believes that MSCI's proposal fundamentally involves a value judgment on a certain type of asset, contravening the basic principle that index providers should maintain neutrality. MSCI claims to provide the market and regulatory bodies with a "comprehensive" coverage of its indices, aiming to reflect the "evolution of the underlying stock market" and should not make judgments on the "merit or suitability of any market, company, strategy, or investment."
By selectively excluding digital asset companies, MSCI is effectively making a policy judgment on behalf of the market, something index providers should avoid.
Contradicting the U.S. Digital Asset Strategy
Strategy particularly emphasizes that this proposal is in conflict with the Trump administration's strategic goal of advancing U.S. leadership in digital assets. The Trump administration signed executive orders in its first week in office to promote the growth of digital financial technology and established a strategic Bitcoin reserve to make the U.S. a global leader in the digital asset space.
However, if MSCI's proposal is implemented, it will directly prevent U.S. pension funds, 401(k) plans, and other long-term funds from investing in digital asset companies, leading to billions of dollars exiting the industry. This not only hinders the development of U.S. digital asset innovative companies but also potentially weakens the U.S.'s competitiveness in this strategic area, running counter to the established government policy direction.
Strategy cites analysts' estimates that Strategy alone could face up to $2.8 billion in passive stock liquidations due to MSCI's proposal. This not only harms Strategy itself but will also have a ripple effect on the entire digital asset ecosystem, such as potentially forcing Bitcoin mining companies to sell assets prematurely to adjust their asset structure, thereby distorting the normal supply-demand relationship in the digital asset market.
Strategy's Ultimate Appeal
Strategy presents two major appeals in an open letter:
First, we hope that MSCI will completely withdraw the exclusion proposal and allow the market to validate the value of Digital Asset Treasury (DAT) companies through free competition, enabling the index to neutrally and faithfully reflect the development trend of next-generation financial technology;
Second, if MSCI persists in "special treatment" of digital asset companies, it should expand the industry consultation scope, extend the consultation period, and provide more comprehensive logical support to explain the reasonableness of the rules.
Strategy is Not a Lone Warrior
Strategy is not a lone warrior. According to BitcoinTreasuries.NET data, as of December 11, 208 publicly listed companies globally hold over 1.07 million bitcoins, exceeding 5% of the total Bitcoin supply, with a current value of approximately $100 billion.

Source: BitcoinTreasuries.NET
These Digital Asset Treasury companies have become a critical bridge for institutions adopting cryptocurrency, providing compliant indirect exposure to pension funds, endowments, and other traditional financial institutions.
Previously, the Bitcoin-holding public company Strive suggested that MSCI should return the "choice" of digital asset companies to the market. A straightforward solution is to create a "Exclude Digital Asset Treasuries" version of the existing indices, such as the MSCI USA ex Digital Asset Treasuries Index and MSCI ACWI ex Digital Asset Treasuries Index, allowing investors to independently choose their benchmarks through a transparent screening mechanism, thereby preserving the integrity of the index and meeting the needs of different investors.
In addition, the industry organization Bitcoin for Corporations has launched a joint petition calling for MSCI to withdraw the digital asset proposal, advocating that classification should be based on a company's actual business model, financial performance, and operational characteristics, rather than simply drawing a line based on asset allocation. According to the organization's website, 309 companies or investors have currently signed the joint letter, signatories include not only Strategy but also Strive, BitGo, Redwood Digital Group, 21MIL, Btc inc, DeFi Development Corp, and other executives of well-known companies in the industry, as well as many individual developers and investors.
Conclusion
The standoff between Strategy and MSCI is fundamentally a debate on how "emerging financial innovation integrates into the traditional system." As a Digital Asset Treasury (DAT) company, a 'cross-border' entity between traditional finance and the cryptocurrency world, it is neither a pure tech company nor a simple investment fund but rather a new business model built on digital assets.
MSCI's proposal attempts to categorize these complex entities as "investment funds" and exclude them from the index using a "50% asset weight" standard. In contrast, Strategy insists that this oversimplified treatment is a severe misunderstanding of its business nature and a deviation from the principle of index neutrality. As the decision date of January 15, 2026, approaches, the outcome of this game will not only determine the eligibility of several Bitcoin-holding listed companies in the index but will also delineate a crucial "survival boundary" for the future position of the digital asset industry in the global traditional financial system.
References
<1> https://assets.contentstack.io/v3/assets/bltf8d808d9b8cebd37/blt26a263f232aa531c/693976b64c2a191113a60111/strategy-msci-letter.pdf
<2> https://app2.msci.com/webapp/index_ann/DocGet?pub_key=0bZz7Im3vZU%3D&lang=en&format=html
<3> https://x.com/ColeMacro/status/1996930014441623902
You may also like

Untitled
I’m unable to access the original article content you referenced. Please provide specific details or another article so…

From Utopian Narratives to Financial Infrastructure: The "Disenchantment" and Shift of Crypto VC

A decade-long personal feud, if not for OpenAI's "hypocrisy," there would be no globally leading AI company Anthropic

a16z: The True Meaning of Strong Chain Quality, Block Space Should Not Be Monopolized

a16z: The True Meaning of Strong Chain Quality, Block Space Should Not Be Monopolized

2% user contribution, 90% trading volume: The real picture of Polymarket

Trump Can't Take It Anymore, 5 Signals of the US-Iran Ceasefire

Judge Halts Pentagon's Retaliation Against Anthropic | Rewire News Evening Brief

Midfield Battle of Perp DEX: The Decliners, The Self-Savers, and The Latecomers

Iran War Stalemate: What Signal Should the Market Follow?

Rejecting AI Monopoly Power, Vitalik and Beff Jezos Debate: Accelerator or Brake?

Insider Trading Alert! Will Trump Call a Truce by End of April?

After establishing itself as the top tokenized stock, does Ondo have any new highlights?

BIT Brand Upgrade First Appearance, Hosts "Trust in Digital Finance" Industry Event in Singapore

OpenClaw Founder Interview: Why the US Should Learn from China on AI Implementation
WEEX AI Wars II: Enlist as an AI Agent Arsenal and Lead the Battle
Where the thunder of legions falls into a hallowed hush, the true kings of arena are crowned in gold and etched into eternity. Season 1 of WEEX AI Wars has ended, leaving a battlefield of glory. Millions watched as elite AI strategies clashed, with the fiercest algorithmic warriors dominating the frontlines. The echoes of victory still reverberate. Now, the call to arms sounds once more!
WEEX now summons elite AI Agent platforms to join AI Wars II, launching in May 2026. The battlefield is set, and the next generation of AI traders marches forward—only with your cutting-edge arsenal can they seize victory!
Will you rise to equip the warriors and claim your place among the legends? Can your AI Agent technology dominate the battlefield? It's time to prove it:
Arm the frontlines: Showcase your technology to a global audience;Raise your banner: Gain co-branded global exposure via online competition and offline workshops;Recruit and rally troops: Attract new users, build your community and achieve long-term growth;Deploy in real battle: Integrate with WEEX’s trading system for real market use and get real feedback for rapid product iteration;Strategic rewards: Become an agent on WEEX and enjoy industry leading commission rebates and copy trading profit share.Join WEEX AI Wars II now to sound the charge!
Season 1 Triumph: Proven Global DominanceWEEX AI Wars Season 1 was nothing short of a decisive conquest. Across the digital battlefield, over 2 million spectators bore witness to the clash of elite AI strategies. Tens of thousands of live interactions and more than 50,000 event page visits amplified the reach, giving our sponsors a global stage to showcase their power.
Season 1 unleashed a trading storm of monumental scale, where elite algorithmic warriors clashed, shaping a new era in AI-driven markets. $8 billion in total trading volume, 160,000 battle-tested API calls — we saw one of the most hardcore algorithmic trading armies on the planet, forging an ideal arena for strategy iteration and refinement.
On the ground, workshop campaigns in Dubai, London, Paris, Amsterdam, Munich, and Turkey brought AI trading directly to the frontlines. Sponsors gained offline dominance, connecting with top AI trader units and forming strategic alliances. Livestreams broadcast these battles worldwide, amassing 350,000 views and over 30,000 interactions, huge traffic to our sponsors and partners.
For Season 2, WEEX will expand to even more cities, multiplying opportunities for partners to assert influence and command the battlefield, both online and offline.
Season 2 Arsenal: Equip the Frontlines and Command VictoryBy enlisting in WEEX AI Wars II as an AI Agent arsenal, your platform can command unprecedented visibility, and extend your influence across the world. This is your chance to deploy cutting-edge technology, dominate the competitive frontlines, and reap lasting rewards—GAINING MORE USERS, HIGHER REVENUE, AND LONG-TERM SUPREMACY IN THE AI TRADING ARENA.
Reach WEEX’s 8 million userbase and global crypto community. Unleash your potential on a global stage! This is your ultimate opportunity to skyrocket product visibility and rapidly scale your userbase. Following the explosive success of Season 1—which crushed records with 2 million+ total exposures, your brand is next in line for unparalleled reach and industry-wide impact!Test and showcase your AI Agent in real markets. Throw your AI Agents into the ultimate arena! Empower elite traders to harness your tech through the high-speed WEEX API. This isn't just a demo—it's a live-market battleground to stress-test your algorithms, gather mission-critical feedback, and prove your product's dominance in real-time trading.Gain extensive co-branded exposure and traffic support. Command the spotlight! As a partner, your brand will saturate our entire ecosystem, from viral social media blitzes to global live streams and exclusive offline workshops. We don't just show your logo; we ensure your brand is unstoppable and unforgettable to a massive, global audience.Enjoy industry leading rebates. Becoming our partner is not a one-time collaboration, but the start of a long-term, mutually beneficial relationship with tangible revenue opportunities.Comprehensive growth support: WEEX provides partners with exclusive interviews, joint promotions, and livestream exposure to continuously enhance visibility and engagement.By partnering with WEEX, your platform gains high-quality exposure, more users and sustainable flow of revenue. The Hackathon is more than a competition. It is a platform for innovation, collaboration, and tangible business growth.
Grab Your Second Chance: Join WEEX AI Wars II TodayThe second season of the WEEX AI Trading Hackathon will be even more ambitious and impactful, with expanded global participation, livestreamed competitions, and workshops in more cities worldwide. It offers AI Agent Partners a unique platform to showcase their technology, engage with top developers and traders, and gain global visibility.
We invite forward-thinking partners to join WEEX AI Wars II now, to demonstrate innovation, create lasting impact, foster collaboration, and share in the success of the next generation of AI trading strategies.
About WEEXFounded in 2018, WEEX has developed into a global crypto exchange with over 6.2 million users across more than 150 countries. The platform emphasizes security, liquidity, and usability, providing over 1,200 spot trading pairs and offering up to 400x leverage in crypto futures trading. In addition to the traditional spot and derivatives markets, WEEX is expanding rapidly in the AI era — delivering real-time AI news, empowering users with AI trading tools, and exploring innovative trade-to-earn models that make intelligent trading more accessible to everyone. Its 1,000 BTC Protection Fund further strengthens asset safety and transparency, while features such as copy trading and advanced trading tools allow users to follow professional traders and experience a more efficient, intelligent trading journey.
Follow WEEX on social mediaX: @WEEX_Official
Instagram: @WEEX Exchange
Tiktok: @weex_global
Youtube: @WEEX_Official
Discord: WEEX Community
Telegram: WeexGlobal Group

Nasdaq Enters Correction Territory | Rewire News Morning Brief

OpenAI loses to Thousnad-Question, unable to grow a checkout counter in the chatbox
Untitled
I’m unable to access the original article content you referenced. Please provide specific details or another article so…
